If your policy includes Uninsured and Underinsured Motorist (UM/UIM) coverage, your own insurance company may be responsible for covering your losses and injuries if the at-fault party’s insurance coverage is insufficient to cover them.
Is it possible to sue your own insurance company?
Suing your own auto insurance provider is uncommon, but it can happen for a variety of reasons.
It’s possible that your insurance company won’t pay all of your physical therapy following an accident. Maybe your insurance company won’t cover you because it thinks you were committing a criminal at the time of the accident. Perhaps the other party in the accident was underinsured, forcing your auto insurance provider to cover the entire cost.
If you get into an accident with someone who isn’t insured or can’t be identified, your own insurance company will fight the claim, according to Allen Wynperle, an Ontario lawyer who handles motor insurance issues. You’re still eligible for accident benefits, but you can’t sue anyone except your insurer for a settlement. “You might sue your own insurance company in that case,” Wynperle explains. “Despite the fact that your insurance company has committed no wrongdoing.”
Suing your auto insurance provider for withholding coverage due to the circumstances surrounding a collision is also an option. While you might anticipate your motor insurance provider to back you up, Wynperle says there are times when they won’t, such as if you committed a crime during the collision, but he adds this is unlikely “It’s quite uncommon.”
In fact, Wynperle claims that a vehicle insurance company refusing to cover you at all is quite rare.
In some provinces, such as Alberta and Saskatchewan, you can sue your own insurance company for accident benefits without having to go through a court system.
However, there may be a problem with how fully it protects you. In November 2018, for example, a group of lawyers representing 15 people filed claims against several of Ontario’s largest insurers, including Aviva, Intact, Belair, and Allstate, alleging that these (and other) insurers had been underpaying vehicle accident victims for years. In some situations, the employers allegedly did not pay or repay HST on accident benefits, while in others, it was included in the calculation. (In court, none of the charges have been proven.)
The insurance companies argue that the case should be resolved through the Licence Appeal Tribunal’s Automobile Accident Benefits Service (LAT-AABS), rather than through the provincial court system.
The LAT-AABS, according to Paul Harte, an Ontario medical malpractice lawyer on the claimants’ legal team, isn’t worth it for many customers. While filing an application costs only $100, Harte maintains that the vast majority of requests are for modest amounts of money less than $150.
“You’re in a situation where you have no access to justice,” he explains.
Can you sue your own insurance company after an accident?
There are a few occasions where you can sue your own insurance provider. The first is when the driver who caused the accident does not have any insurance. According to the Texas Department of Motor Vehicles, one out of every five drivers, or 20%, does not carry liability insurance. If you are hit by an uninsured driver, your next step is to file a claim with your own insurance provider. This is also true if you are involved in a hit-and-run accident and are unable to locate the other driver. Because uninsured/underinsured coverage is an optional insurance that must be purchased, I strongly advise everyone to check their policies to ensure they have enough of it.
Can you sue your insurance company for pain and suffering?
If you were hurt in a car accident, you may be able to sue your own insurance company for your pain and suffering, as well as any damages that exceed your policy limits. You must, however, meet certain standards.
According to the New York Department of Financial Services, personal injury protection (PIP) coverage is a required auto insurance policy for all drivers in New York (DFS). Regardless of fault, your PIP policy will cover your eligible expenditures and losses up to $50,000. Here’s how you can go above and beyond this restriction.
Will car insurance pay for pain and suffering?
In the event of an accident, an automotive insurance coverage will compensate for pain and suffering damages. These payments are usually made out of the bodily injury liability element of the policy. It will also pay for any lost wages or medical bills incurred as a result of the accident.
The limitations of bodily injury liability coverage are determined by the quantity of coverage acquired by the motorist in their insurance. As a result, if the driver’s bodily injury responsibility is only $50,000, the insurer is only obligated to pay $50,000 in medical expenditures, lost income, and pain and suffering. If you’ve suffered a catastrophic injury, that amount is unlikely to pay your medical bills and lost wages, much alone damages for pain and suffering.
Unfortunately, once the benefits have been spent, the insurer is not obligated to pay much. As a result, once the policy has been exhausted, the defendant is legally obligated to pay the balance – if they have the financial means to do so.
Insurance Claims Adjusters Will Scrutinize Every Piece of Evidence
An adjuster for an insurance claim will examine each piece of evidence and attempt to refute your requests for pain and suffering damages. They may claim you had pre-existing injuries or that you exaggerated your ailments following the accident. They may also want to know how long it took you to receive medical help. They may wonder how you went a full 24 hours without treatment for something so serious if your injuries are significant and you waited over a day.
If you have an attorney working on your case, you won’t have to worry about this. Your lawyer is familiar with the games insurance companies play and the arguments they will use to refute your claim. That means they’ll be prepared to fight any denials with proof, and they’ll work hard to reach an agreement that assures you get the money you deserve.
Using the Modifier and Formula to Calculate Pain and Suffering
When estimating how much pain and suffering damages you deserve, insurance firms frequently apply a modifier. They will multiply the total amount of your medical bills by a number they believe is appropriate for your injury. The larger the multiplier, the more serious or lasting the harm. The lower it goes, the less severe and durable it is.
After multiplying your medical expenses, they’ll add in your lost wages and any loss of earning ability claims you made to arrive at a pain and suffering figure that will always be less than what your attorney estimates.
Is it worth suing after a car accident?
Not every vehicle accident claim necessitates the filing of a lawsuit. Suing after an automobile accident is almost never necessary. If no one was wounded and the other motorist has insurance, the other driver’s insurance company is likely to compensate you for your repairs. However, in some cases, suing after a car accident is a good idea.
If your insurance claim was denied, you were offered an unusually low payment, or the insurance company refused to discuss, you may want to consider taking legal action.
Compensation should include both proven expenditures (such as medical and repair bills) and pain and suffering. Only after someone has been physically hurt in a car accident does pain and suffering come into play. When you sue after a car accident, the greater your injury is, the more money you’ll collect for pain and suffering. However, calculating pain and suffering can be subjective. The insurance provider is most likely to undervalue you in this area.
You may have no choice but to file a lawsuit if the other driver does not have insurance. Most lawyers advise against it because persons who do not have insurance may not have any assets to take. This means that even if you win your lawsuit, the other party will be unable to compensate you. It is normally preferable to file a claim with your own uninsured driver insurance coverage in these situations (if you have one).
What recourse do I have against an insurance company?
Where do you go if you have a complaint about your insurance company? Dianne Zeitler was curious about this after breaking her arm while vacationing in Vienna, Austria.
“My insurance company rejected my claim twice when I asked for reimbursement for emergency surgery,” recalls Zeitler, a former health care consultant from Washington, D.C.
She, like many other policyholders, had a variety of options for submitting a complaint. Should she file a claim with her insurance company? Should she file a complaint with her state’s insurance commissioner? Should she see an attorney?
“A policyholder has various options when an insurance company refuses to honor its contract or follow the law,” says Jeff Raizner, a partner at Raizner Slania, a Houston law practice that specializes in insurance litigation.
- File a complaint with the state insurance department, which oversees insurance activities and ensures that insurers follow state rules and regulations.
Zeitler first went with door number three. She filed a complaint with the appeals department of her insurance company, which is overseen by a third party because it is run by the government. She did, however, hedge her chances by opening door number two. She tracked down the names of the insurance company’s board of directors and executives and wrote them a nice letter.
“I included a claim timeline, names and departments to whom I spoke, and copies of the bills,” she explains.
Can someone sue you after insurance pays?
It can be tough and unpleasant to deal with the aftermath of an automobile accident, including the settlement procedure. When an insurance settlement is handed out, many persons involved in vehicle accidents feel relieved because they believe it means there will be no more litigation. Even if this is usually the case, it is still conceivable for someone to sue you after your insurance has paid out.
Can you sue an insurance company for lying?
You have several options when it comes to filing a lawsuit against your insurance company. It’s worth noting that you can sue your insurer for multiple reasons.
Suing an Insurance Company for Negligence
Negligence is defined as a failure to act or comply with the requirements of a legal agreement from a legal standpoint. You may be able to sue an insurer for gross negligence, which is defined as a failure to act that leads to a disregard for safety.
If your insurance acted or failed to act in a way that caused you harm, you can sue them for negligence or gross negligence:
- You can claim for negligence if your insurance agent fails to offer the coverage you requested or fails to advise you of your options.
- If your insurance company neglected to explain or misrepresented about what your policy covers, you could file a negligence case. You might claim for deception if they lied about your coverage.
- If your insurance fails to fulfill its obligations, you might initiate a negligence case. It can include not responding to a claim or appeals letter or failing to perform a thorough inquiry.
- You could claim for negligence if your insurance provider failed to warn you that they were going bankrupt or that your coverage was about to expire.