If you plan to audit your claims internally, at least one member of your team should be assigned to the task. Depending on the amount of claims you chose to examine, your audit team may require multiple members.
If you don’t have anybody in-house with the necessary experience to lead an internal audit, you should hire an external auditing firm. If you opt to hire an external auditor, simply follow their initial instructions before moving on to Step Six.
Step Two: Pull a sample of your medical claims
Once you’ve determined who will lead your audit, you’ll need to pick a time frame for the audit and select a sample of your current claims. You may, for example, audit a sample of claims from a specific week, month, or quarter. The number of claims included in a sample is usually determined by the practice’s number of providers.
Physician practices should pull 10-20 claims per physician, according to Veronica Bradley, Senior Industry Advisor with the Medical Group Management Association (MGMA), whereas hospital departments may need a larger sample of 25 to 30 claims. If you employ an outside company to audit your claims, they will almost always look at your physician data and set the parameters for the sample they will look at.
Step Three: Carefully review each claim for accuracy
Your auditors will begin the review process now that a sample of your claims has been pulled. This is the most time-consuming phase in the audit process, especially if your sample size is considerable. This process starts with gathering all relevant claim documentation, such as clinical records and financial information, such as payment receipts.
With all pertinent evidence in hand, evaluate the claim to see if it has accurate data and orders that have been signed and dated by the physician. Then look for coding mistakes like undercoding and overcoding. Finally, go over the claim again to make sure that existing policies and standards are being followed.
Step Four: Make a list of mistakes and discrepancies
As you progress through the audit, you will almost certainly discover certain medical billing errors that will have a significant impact on your revenue. It’s critical to keep track of any errors or discrepancies you find so that you can make the necessary changes to your claims procedures. While every practice is unique, there are a few typical blunders that might lead to an increase in the number of refused claims:
- Address problems and wrong birthdates are examples of inaccuracy in identifying information.
Step Five: Organize audit findings in a report
If you decide to conduct an internal audit, make sure your lead auditor documents all findings in a professional report. While there are no hard and fast rules for audit reporting, there are a few crucial components that should be included. Your report should include the following information at a minimum:
- An executive summary of your audit findings, which provides a high-level overview.
- The audit’s scope, includes the size of the sample and the duration of the audit
Step Six: Review your audit findings with staff
It’s time to evaluate the findings with your team once you’ve received the audit report. While it’s a good idea to involve your complete team in the assessment, you might want to set out some time to spend with the employees who work with your claims the most. Make sure to mention the following three points as you go over your audit report:
Step Seven: Map out a plan to address deficiencies
If you don’t draw out a plan to fix common errors and weak places, the best, most complete audit reports in the world will be useless. The strategy you create should be based on the findings of your audit and the nature of your inadequacies. If your audit indicates that all of your practice’s physicians are using outdated codes, it’s time to refresh your training and plan an in-service on coding and guideline revisions.
Step Eight: Schedule your next claims audit
“Audits might be done on a monthly, quarterly, twice-yearly, or annual basis… Processes with a long history of defects or non-conformities should be audited more frequently, such as quarterly or twice a year.”
What do insurance auditors look for?
A general liability insurance audit looks at the payroll and risk exposure of your company. An audit ensures that you’re paying the correct amount for general liability insurance and that you’re obtaining enough coverage for your company.
Do insurance companies audit claims?
In order to prevent fraud and abuse within the health payment system, health insurance payers monitor the billing, coding, and documentation methods of health care providers. The post-payment audit or retroactive examination of claims is a standard procedure used by insurers. In most cases, the insurer will request medical documents from the provider and then match the documentation to the codes on previously submitted and paid claim forms. If the documentation contains any flaws or does not comply with the insurer’s payment policies (e.g., medical necessity requirements), the insurer will calculate an overpayment demand. The provider will be asked to repay the insurer for the overpayment. If the provider fails to pay the amount owed, the insurer will frequently employ the self-help remedy of balancing the sums owed against the provider’s current claim submissions. Recoupment is the term used to describe the process of collecting overpayments.
Billing, coding, and documentation compliance should be prioritized by physicians and other licensed practitioners. If the provider is audited, learning the proper use of codes, documentation requirements, and other payer policy details may help to prevent the audit or reduce the likelihood of an overpayment determination. The ten most common audit risk areas that providers should focus on as part of any compliance training and education are listed below:
- Failure to follow medical guidelines. Medical policies are created by all insurers and must be followed to the letter. Medical policies specify the documents that insurers demand to substantiate claims that are submitted for payment. All insurance payer medical policies should be downloaded and reviewed, and office policies and procedures for training, educating, and complying with those policies should be implemented.
- Maintenance vs. Medical Necessity Insurance companies frequently devote special attention to a patient’s long-term care without showing functional progress or the need for specific therapies. Overpayment determinations are frequently the result of failure to properly document medically essential services.
- Codes that are based on time. Physical medicine codes demand that one-on-one time between the clinician and the patient be documented. Any violation of the rules for invoicing time-based codes by the provider will result in an overpayment determination.
- Individual vs. Group Therapy: What’s the Difference? A one-on-one therapy session versus a session with two or more patients must be appropriately reported by providers.
- Using the incorrect code. Providers are expected to file claims using the codes that best describe the patient’s services. When the erroneous code is used, an overpayment determination is made, and in some situations, a fraud claim is filed if the payer feels it was done on purpose.
- Up-coding. While an improper code is utilized to obtain a greater level of reimbursement, for example, reporting CPT 99203 when CPT 99201 more accurately represents the services, this occurs.
- Evaluation and management are overused. Only when an evaluation and management service is medically required must it be reported. Payers will examine practices that employ the evaluation and management codes on a regular basis to see if the tests are essential.
- Service Delegation to Unlicensed Personnel Unlicensed staff are frequently prohibited from providing services to patients by payer rules and state law, even when supervised by a licensed clinician. Payers will reclaim money if claims are lodged for services inappropriately delivered by unlicensed persons.
- Inadequate supervision. Individuals can undertake treatments and diagnostic testing in some cases as long as they are appropriately supervised. An overpayment determination will be made due to poor supervision.
- Improper Modifier Use: Improper modifier use might easily result in an audit or reimbursement complications.
An audit by an insurance payer is a possibility for all health-care providers. Providers are advised to educate and train their staff and licensed professionals ahead of time to avoid difficulties that frequently result in audits. Providers can preserve their reimbursement by taking proactive compliance measures.
How do insurance companies audit?
Isn’t the word “audit” the absolute worst? The IRS and government personnel are usually the first persons that come to mind when they think about financial investigations. An insurance audit, on the other hand, is a separate process and far less terrifying than an IRS audit.
By the end of this article, we hope you’ll have a better understanding of what an insurance audit is, why carriers conduct them, and how you can prepare so you’re not caught off guard.
What is an insurance audit?
An insurance audit is a means for a carrier to figure out how much risk they actually insured in the previous year. During the year that your policy was in place, the company could have undergone significant changes.
The premiums that carriers charge for general liability (GL) and workers compensation insurance are determined by a number of factors. Certain estimates that you self-report to the carrier, such as sales and payroll, are among the most essential of those criteria. They accept your word for it that these data are correct…at least for the time being.
The majority of GL insurance are priced primarily on the basis of sales “rating criterion.” During the application process, the carrier inquires about your predicted revenue for the next 12 months, and then issues the policy based on that information.
Payroll figures are used to price workers’ compensation (and, in some situations, general liability). Of course, the riskiness of the work that employees do is important, but that riskiness is represented as a number “The entire payroll for those employees is multiplied by a “class modifier” that is multiplied by…you got it…the total payroll for those employees.
If you expect $X in revenue and $Y in payroll, and those estimates treble the following year because business is booming, the carrier was taking on more risk than you paid for that year.
As a result, the carrier does an audit. They ask you for your actual numbers from the previous year, and then charge you the difference between what you paid and what the premium should’ve been, using the same rate that you were promised at the start of the year.
As a result, the price is shown as “estimated premium” or “advance premium” on these plans. It’s the most accurate estimate of the policy’s cost. Once the policy time has ended, the real price is decided.
What’s the timeline of an insurance audit?
- You fill out an application that details the number of employees, their job titles, and the amount of payroll each position receives.
- Your broker submits your application to a number of carriers, negotiates, gathers estimates, and then delivers them to you.
- The carrier sends you a letter with a “audit worksheet” within 3 months (typically sooner).
- You fill up the spreadsheet with your previous year’s real payroll. Let’s imagine it was 10% greater than anticipated.
- The carrier examines the policy and then offers an endorsement, revising it and charging a higher premium.
- You pay the additional fee if you agree with the audit results, and you’re ready to move on to the next year!
- If you believe there was an error or misunderstanding, you can challenge the audit, and your broker can force the carrier to recalculate. Carriers will only undertake on-site audits in exceptional circumstances. There’s no reason to be concerned! This is often a brief meeting during which the carrier’s agent inspects the operation and double-checks the figures with you.
Here’s an example:
There are two categories of staff employed by a helmet company: clerical and testing. Employees in the clerical department send emails and crunch figures. The testers have a more distinctive duty in that they must determine the effectiveness of the helmets. Tester Joe is in the category of “dropping from ladders,” whereas Tester Susan is in the category of “look out, sledgehammer incoming.”
What should be included in an insurance audit?
The information listed below is typical of what an auditor might ask for during an audit. If a policy covers numerous firms or entities, the auditor will ask for this information for each company or entity separately.
- Bonuses, commissions, holiday pay, sick pay, overtime pay, vacation pay, and all pretax sums are included in gross pay.
How do you survive an insurance audit?
Although a premium audit may appear to be time-consuming, it is not. Here’s how to be informed and prepared during the term of your coverage.
When a workers’ compensation policy or other type of small business insurance policy reaches the end of its term, it is usually subjected to a premium audit. What is the explanation for this? Your insurer calculated your policy’s premium based on projections of your payroll and employee statistics, as well as gross sales, during the course of your policy’s term, and now wants to determine whether those calculations were accurate. (If this is the case, your premium for the remaining term may be modified up or down.)
Although a premium audit may appear to be time-consuming, it is not. Taking certain actions ahead of time, on the other hand, can make things considerably easier for you and your firm. Here are five crucial points to remember if you’re facing a premium audit.
1. Keep track of your payroll and sales data and make sure it’s up to date.
Compare your real payroll and sales data to the figures in your policy documents on a regular basis. If your payroll and sales appear to be significantly more or lower than expected, call your insurance agent so that modifications can be made. This guarantees that you have the payroll or sales data that your insurer will require during the audit, and reduces the chances of a big premium adjustment at the conclusion of your policy’s term.
2. Correctly classify your employees
The sort of work your employees undertake determines your workers’ compensation premium. As a result, it’s critical to keep your job categories up to date and precise, as your insurer may want to see this information during an audit.
The National Council on Compensation Insurance (NCCI) sets and maintains the codes used to categorize employees for workers’ compensation purposes, however a few states have their own worker categorization systems.
3. Keep Financial Documents Organized
Providing up-to-date financial records, whether your most recent quarterly 941 or Schedule C tax forms or your general sales ledger, is an important part of a premium audit. The insurer will also want to see high-level information about all firm owners, officers, and partners, including their titles, places of employment, stock ownership percentages, and earnings for the audit period. When it comes time to file your premium audit, keeping these records organized and easily accessible can make the process much faster and easier for you.
4. Examine your 1099s
Certain contractors or subcontractors may be qualified for coverage under your workers’ compensation policy under state workers’ compensation rules, even if you issue them a 1099 rather than a W-2. Because the definition of “employee” for insurance purposes varies by state, it’s critical to double-check that anyone you’ve designated as an independent contractor isn’t actually an employee.
5. Submit your audit reports on time
Your insurer will request that you provide the required paperwork and information by a certain date. Make sure you stick to the deadline. It will make the process run more smoothly and efficiently, as well as ensure that any premium adjustments are correct.
A premium audit is typically a short process, with results arriving within a few weeks of submitting the needed payroll and/or sales information. You can be sure you’ll be ready for the audit if you stay organized and prepare the documents and information your insurer will want to examine during the audit.
The information in these papers is intended to be general in nature and to be used as a guideline. It is not intended to be taken as legal advice. The Hartford does not guarantee that implementing any of the views or recommendations provided herein will: I eliminate any harmful circumstances at your business sites or in your business operations; or (ii) constitute an appropriate legal or business practice. The Hartford assumes no responsibility for the control or correction of hazards or legal compliance with respect to your business practices, and the views and recommendations contained herein do not imply that we will determine or warrant that your business premises, locations, or operations are safe or healthy, or that they comply with any law, rule, or regulation on your behalf or for the benefit of others. Readers should consult their safety consultant, attorney, or business consultants if they have specific safety, legal, or business issues or concerns about the information presented in these pages.
Hartford Fire Insurance Company and its connected property and casualty insurance firms are located at 690 Asylum Avenue in Hartford, Connecticut 06155.
Certain insurance policies differ by state and may not be available to all businesses. All Hartford coverages and services discussed on this page may be offered by one or more of The Hartford Financial Services Group, Inc.’s property and casualty insurance business subsidiaries. Sentinel Insurance Company, Ltd., Hartford Casualty Insurance Company, Hartford Lloyd’s Insurance Company, Property and Casualty Insurance Company of Hartford, Hartford Underwriters Insurance Company, Twin City Fire Insurance Company, Hartford Accident and Indemnity Company, and Hartford Fire Insurance Company are among the companies that write this insurance in Texas. Sentinel Insurance Company, Ltd. (CA license # 8701) and its property and casualty insurance company affiliates, 690 Asylum Avenue, Hartford, CT 06155. In CA by Sentinel Insurance Company, Ltd. (CA license # 8701) and its property and casualty insurance company affiliates, 690 Asylum Avenue, Hartford, CT 06155.
ADP, LLC’s insurance agency, Automatic Data Processing Insurance Agency, Inc. (ADPIA), is a subsidiary of ADP, LLC. All insurance products shall be provided and sold exclusively by ADPIA, its licensed agents, or licensed insurance partners at 1 ADP Blvd., Roseland, NJ 07068. CA license #0D04044. There are 50 states where you can get a license. It’s possible that not all services are offered in every state. One of ADPIA’s carrier partners is The Hartford. The Hartford does not have an exclusive agent with ADPIA. This material isn’t meant to be taken as legal or tax advice. Contact a tax or legal specialist if you have any queries.
Tags:
Compensation for Employees
Classification of Workers
Insights & Research
Compliance with the Tax Code
Compliance and Risk
HRMultinationalArticles
FinanceMid-Sized Enterprise
Large Corporations
Can you refuse an insurance audit?
What happens if an employer fails to reply to an insurance company’s audit request? An unresponsive audit is what it’s called, and it can have a long-term impact on a business owner. Let’s take a look at what’s going on here.
An audit of the expired policy period is required before the actual premium for a workers compensation policy can be established. Because the insurance sold to a company is solely based on a prediction of payroll incurred throughout the policy period, this is the case. Premium = rate x payroll / 100 is the formula. So, until the policy expires and an audit is done, you won’t know what the payroll is.
When an employer purchases an insurance, they agree to have an audit performed. It’s spelled out in the insurance contract: the insurance company will pay claims if the employer pays the premium. The audit is also included in the premium procedure.
As a result, when an employer fails to finish an audit, it creates an issue. It’s a promise that’s been broken. Now you have an insurance firm that has provided coverage for the employer’s employees for the duration of the policy, but is unable to determine the final premium because the employer refuses to allow the audit to be completed.
- Cancel the current policy: An insurance company will view the employer’s refusal to conduct an audit as a failure to meet the policy’s responsibilities. They will have no choice but to cancel the present insurance because the original policy period has expired. And they’re going to do it.
- Conduct An Estimated Audit: Just because the employer has opted not to allow an audit, doesn’t imply it won’t be done! That’s true, it’s known as an estimated audit, and it’ll be performed by the insurance company without the employer’s participation. Estimated audits are a pain in the neck! An expected audit will almost always be a multiple of the original projected payroll. The automated adjustment ranges between 25% and 300 percent!!
- Produce an Additional Premium Invoice: After an estimated audit is finished, the insurance company will generate an invoice and send it to the employer for payment.
- The account will be turned over to collections if the employer does not pay the increased premium bill. This includes all of the positive aspects of working with a collecting agency.
- Taking Legal Action Against Your Employer: This is a recent trend that we’ve noticed. If the insurance company suspects that the employer has acted fraudulently, it may file fraud charges and sue for damages.
- Notify Advisory Organization Of Unpaid Balance: Depending on the type of policy in question, notifying the advisory organization of an unpaid balance may prevent the employer from obtaining coverage from another source until the outstanding balance is paid.
I’m sure there are other things an insurance company can do if an employer refuses to cooperate with an audit, but these are the ones that come to mind.
What did you learn as a result of this experience? When it comes to auditing, don’t screw around and stick to the process. If you suspect a problem with your audit after it’s been finished, seek outside assistance and have an audit review performed.
What happens if you fail an insurance audit?
The severity of the problem determines the audit’s unfavorable outcomes. Payers will, at the very least, ask the doctor to repay reimbursements for services that the audit process determined were not medically necessary or not documented. The penalty will escalate in proportion to the severity of the offense. Audit judgments can include fines per service item billed, probationary punishments, withdrawal from the plan, and even criminal penalties, in addition to the return of funds collected. The harsher penalties can almost always be avoided by simply understanding and adhering to ethical patient care decisions and specific payer laws.
What happens when an insurance company audits you?
An insurance audit is a standard procedure in the insurance sector. An audit is a review of your company’s operations, records, and books of account to determine your actual insurance exposure, including premium basis, classifications, and rates for a given period of time.
How long does an insurance company have to audit a claim?
The review or audit of a health care provider’s claims by an insurer that results in the recoupment or set-off of money previously paid to the provider must be completed no later than two years after the completed claims were paid.
Why do insurance companies ask for financials?
When providing new business and renewal bids, underwriters usually seek financial statements. This is because insurability, dedication to loss control measures, and ability to pay premiums are all influenced by an insured’s financial situation.